Is Your SEO Agency Working? When to Switch
Your SEO agency is working if you can point to specific work each month, rankings for money keywords are moving, and leads from organic search are rising. If you cannot trace your monthly fee to specific deliverables, you are not getting a measurable service. Have one direct conversation first, then get an independent audit before you switch. If you would rather have a second opinion, schedule an appointment with ThreadLink.
You have paid your agency for months. The reports keep arriving, the numbers look busy, and your phone is not ringing any more than it was.
That is the position most owners are in when they start doubting an agency. The doubt is usually right to raise and wrong to act on before you have evidence, because firing a good agency early costs as much as keeping a bad one.
This guide gives you a fair test, the warning signs, and a safe way to switch if the evidence says you should. If you are still choosing an agency, start with our guide to choosing an SEO agency in Orlando.
Your SEO agency is working when you can see specific work done each month, rankings for real money keywords are climbing, and leads from organic search are rising. Judge the work from month one and the results over months.
Ask what they did last month. A real agency answers with specifics: pages changed, fixes shipped, content published, listings updated. A coasting one cannot (OPO SEO).
Look at impressions in Search Console, technical issues closed, and rankings for the searches your buyers actually use. Vanity terms do not count.
Ask how many leads SEO generated in the last three months. If the agency cannot answer, or answers only in rankings, that is the problem (GoBIG).
Do not fire an agency over one slow month. Early ranking signals typically take 60 to 90 days to appear, and the agency should still be showing work every month before then. Flat rankings after six months of steady payment, with no visible change to your site, is a different story.
Confirm you have admin access to your Google Business Profile, Search Console, and analytics. Then spot-check your backlinks in the free Links report in Search Console, looking at 20 random source domains (Baldwin Digital).
Want an outside read on where you stand? Schedule an appointment with ThreadLink and we will walk through it with you.
Before you fire anyone, ask four questions: What did you do last month? Which keywords moved? How many leads has SEO produced in the last three months? What is the plan for the next 90 days? A confident agency welcomes them.
Google ranks your site, not your agency, and a well-managed switch preserves what you have built (Sun Media Marketing). Five mistakes cause almost every ranking drop during a switch:
A third-party audit gives you an objective picture of your technical health, content, backlinks, and what work has actually been done. It is not about finding fault. It gives you the basis to stay or switch without second-guessing.
Document your technical setup, content inventory, link profile, and redirect maps. Then ask for a written 90-day plan before you sign. Our guide to the first 90 days with an SEO agency shows what that plan should contain.
Want a scope that fits your business? Schedule an appointment with ThreadLink. Every engagement is scoped to the client, so pricing is quoted after that conversation.
ThreadLink is a web design and branding agency based in Clermont, in the Orlando metro area. Every engagement is scoped to the client, so the mix of work depends on what your team already covers. We build SEO around the way your customers search, and we report on leads and pipeline impact, not followers or impressions. The work can include:
Hauff Homes, a ThreadLink client, said we were not 'flighty or difficult to pin down' (Hauff Homes, Google review). ThreadLink holds a 5.0 rating on Google and has been Lake County's award-winning agency year over year since 2023.
See the work in our portfolio, or read about our web design and branding work for Orlando businesses.
If you want to walk through where you stand and what a realistic plan looks like, schedule an appointment with ThreadLink. Every engagement is scoped to the client, so pricing is quoted after that conversation.
Ask what they did last month. A working agency answers with specifics such as pages changed, fixes shipped, content published, and listings updated. Check that your website actually changes over time and that reports differ from month to month.
Give it at least 60 to 90 days for early ranking signals, and judge the work each month from the start. Flat rankings after six months of steady payment, with no visible changes to your site, is a strong reason to act.
Identical monthly reports, a website that never changes, unanswered questions, an undefined contract, spammy backlinks, vague answers such as 'trust the process', and flat rankings for six months or more.
Not if it is managed well. Almost every ranking drop during a switch comes from five mistakes: losing account access, changing URL structures unnecessarily, removing key pages, breaking redirect chains, and rushing major changes before the new agency understands the site.
Ask what they did last month, which keywords moved, how many leads SEO has produced in the last three months, and what the plan is for the next 90 days. A confident agency welcomes these questions.
You should. Your Google Business Profile, Search Console, analytics, website, and content should all be in accounts you control. Confirm you have admin access before you make any decision.
They can. Check your backlinks in Search Console's free Links report. Foreign-language spam, casino sites, and networks of look-alike domains point to low-quality link building that you should raise with the agency or address in a switch.
Yes, whether you plan to stay or switch. A qualified third-party audit shows your technical health, content, backlinks, and what work has and has not been done, so the decision rests on evidence.
ThreadLink is a web design and branding agency in Clermont. Every engagement is scoped to the client, so the mix of work depends on what your team already covers. For SEO, the work can include a Google Business Profile audit and cleanup, a content and keyword strategy built around how Orlando customers search, review management, and monthly reports focused on leads. Pricing is quoted after a conversation, which you can schedule on our contact page.
Let's talk. Book a free strategy call and find out what's possible for your business.
Essential cookies are always active. You can enable or disable the rest.
Required for the site to function. Cannot be disabled.
Helps us understand how people use the site (GA4, Hotjar). Data is pseudonymized.
Enables personalized ads via Google tag and similar tools.
